January 6 Pardons Were Justified
Myth
False. Trump pardoned 1,500+ criminals, including hundreds of violent criminals convicted of assaulting police. It tells future extremists that certain political violence will not have consequences. The Associated Press
Argument
Trump Pardoned Serious, Violent Criminal Convictions
January 6 defendants were convicted by juries or pled guilty themselves in open court. They were afforded full due process rights. The Associated Press
Examples
- David Dempsey, sentenced to 20 years, stomped on police officers’ heads, struck an officer in the head with a metal crutch, and attacked police with pepper spray and broken pieces of furniture. He was pardoned by Donald Trump.
- Daniel Joseph ‘‘DJ’’ Rodriguez, sentenced to over 12 years, repeatedly drove a taser into the neck of Officer Mike Fanone causing him to lose consciousness and have a heart attack. He was pardoned by Donald Trump.
- Daniel Ball was held in pretrial detention because of hurling an explosive device into the lower west terrace tunnel of the Capitol. He was released by President Trump, but was later rearrested on a gun charge.
See the myth January 6 was Peaceful for more details.
Trump Framed Rioters as “Hostages” and “Patriots” to Whitewash His Involvement
- On the five-year anniversary of January 6, the official Trump White House website featured a narrative defending participants as “peaceful patriotic protestors,” explicitly reframing them as patriots rather than rioters.
- This rhetoric exists to invert victim and perpetrator dynamic and whitewash Trump’s involvement in the insurrection.
"Why are they still being held? Nobody’s ever been treated like this. Nobody’s ever. Maybe the Japanese during the Second World War, frankly."
Donald J. Trump, on The Dan Bongino Show on Oct. 18, 2024.
Why it matters
Pardoning people convicted of attacking police and stopping the peaceful transfer of power rewards political violence. It tells future extremists that there are no consequences for violence on behalf of a political cause.
Common Objections
Add Objection